The past is the past

According to an Ontario Securities Commission study released last year, 44% of the DIY investors surveyed by the OSC said they opt for self-directed investing because they enjoy it.

But fun has been in short supply for investors since the latter part of 2021, when growth and tech stocks hit a wall. Inflation continues to nibble away at returns. Some analysts expect higher interest rates to be rolled out by central banks in the U.S. and Canada in the early months of this year.

DIY investors looking at today’s market need to recognize that 2022, like every year, is its own animal. Expecting equities to behave like they did in 2020 or early 2021, when the market was being driven by a unique confluence of government stimulus, hype and free time, is an error waiting to happen, says Chris Karram, managing partner at SafeBridge Private Wealth.

“The reality is, in almost every scenario, that the winner last year is not ‘the one’ this year,” Karram says. “If you were to look at sectors, regions or otherwise over the course of a 20- or 30-year window, without question, it's never the same sector, or never the same region, that wins three years in a row.”

The energy sector, for example, had been languishing for years until 2021, when higher crude oil prices and a sudden recovery in energy stocks helped drive the S&P/TSX Composite Index to its best performance since 2009.

Avoiding oil stocks last year based on their prior weakness feels like it would have been the right move, doesn’t it? But it would have resulted in missing out on one of the year’s tastiest rebounds.

Join Masterworks to invest in works by Banksy, Picasso, Kaws, and more. Use our special link to skip the waitlist and join an exclusive community of art investors.

Skip waitlist

Keep your expectations realistic

Mark Yamada, president of PUR Investing, says investors often gravitate toward DIY whenever the market goes on an extended bull run and picking stocks looks easy.

“You did not have to be a genius” to pick winners in 2020, Yamada says. “You just had to buy something, and it would go up.”

That expectation still appears to be in effect for at least some investors, particularly those too young to remember the early 2000s dot-com crash or the 2008 financial meltdown.

“Gen Z have only seen the market go up, with the exception of 2020. And what they're expecting from the market is really extraordinary,” says Yamada.

In a survey conducted by American financial services company Capital Group in March of 2020, millennial investors said they expect a 15% annual return on their investments. Gen Zs said they’re expecting returns of 26%.

It’s a phenomenon Yamada attributes to young investors’ belief in “buying the dip.”

For perspective, the annual rate of return on the S&P/TSX Composite Index was 9.3% between 1960 and 2020, according to an analysis by Morningstar.

Some experts expect future returns to fall well short of that figure. A recent Credit Suisse report says Gen Z investors, whom the bank defines as those born between 1997 and 2012, should be expecting annualized returns more in the range of 2% in the coming years.

Could such a sudden reversal be possible after the strength the market has displayed in the past two years? Absolutely.

As Credit Suisse explains, in the 20 years leading up to 2000, the historical real annualized return on global equities had been 10.5%. But from 2000 to 2010, the average was -0.6%, thanks to the beating handed out by the Great Financial Crisis. Times change.

“You never know what the return of the market is going to be,” Yamada says.

Get good intel

Watching GameStop’s stock slide more than 30% in the last six months should have you wondering whether you should keep getting your investment advice from complete strangers on Reddit.

Investing for yourself requires a steady diet of information. Just be sure to check where it comes from.

“The challenge with today's world, I think more than anything, is that everything has a bit of a bias,” Karram says.

Banks and investment firms can provide useful resources, but it’s also their job to sell you their own products. Certain websites and social media influencers promise insider techniques and stealthy stock picks, but they also want to sell you premium memberships and passes to expensive weekend seminars.

“The average investor is going to have to really work hard to find unbiased advice,” Karram says. “It's almost impossible to point anyone in the right direction, because whoever came up with great advice last year doesn't necessarily have great advice this year.”

Whoever you’re getting your information from should have an extended track record of success that’s taken place in different market environments.

Don't let your portfolio get dragged down by commission fees. Wealthsimple Trade lets you trade for $0 commission, and for a limited time, you can get two free stocks for signing up and funding your account. Will you get Apple stock? How about Air Canada?

Get your free stocks

Know yourself

Even though both Karram and Yamada make a living advising people what to do with their money, neither discourages investors from going it alone.

“Good for them,” Yamada says. “They will never believe that the market is a difficult and complex place unless they actually experience it themselves. It's better for them to get the experience of getting their knuckles rapped and their accounts buried when they don't have very much money.”

Both believe DIY investors need to have a solid understanding of who they are before placing any bets on the market.

“Are you the type of person that can make and stick to your investment decisions? Do you have the discipline and the execution to see them through? Or are you the person who needs advice and direction?” Karram says.

Investing for long-term success means investing strategically. You won’t be able to do that without knowing what you want and what you’re prepared to do to get it.

“Nobody,” says Yamada, “can know the psychology of an investor better than [they] themselves.”

Fine art as an investment

Stocks can be volatile, cryptos make big swings to either side, and even gold is not immune to the market’s ups and downs.

That’s why if you are looking for the ultimate hedge, it could be worthwhile to check out a real, but overlooked asset: fine art.

Contemporary artwork has outperformed the S&P 500 by a commanding 174% over the past 25 years, according to the Citi Global Art Market chart.

And it’s becoming a popular way to diversify because it’s a real physical asset with little correlation to the stock market.

On a scale of -1 to +1, with 0 representing no link at all, Citi found the correlation between contemporary art and the S&P 500 was just 0.12 during the past 25 years.

Earlier this year, Bank of America investment chief Michael Harnett singled out artwork as a sharp way to outperform over the next decade — due largely to the asset’s track record as an inflation hedge.

Investing in art by the likes of Banksy and Andy Warhol used to be an option only for the ultrarich. But with a new investing platform, you can invest in iconic artworks just like Jeff Bezos and Bill Gates do.

About the Author

Clayton Jarvis

Clayton Jarvis

Reporter

Clayton Jarvis is a mortgage reporter at MoneyWise. Prior to joining the MoneyWise team, Clay wrote for and edited a variety of real estate publications, including Canadian Real Estate Wealth, Real Estate Professional, Mortgage Broker News, Canadian Mortgage Professional, and Mortgage Professional America.

What to Read Next

Disclaimer

The content provided on MoneyWise is information to help users become financially literate. It is neither tax nor legal advice, is not intended to be relied upon as a forecast, research or investment advice, and is not a recommendation, offer or solicitation to buy or sell any securities or to adopt any investment strategy. Tax, investment and all other decisions should be made, as appropriate, only with guidance from a qualified professional. We make no representation or warranty of any kind, either express or implied, with respect to the data provided, the timeliness thereof, the results to be obtained by the use thereof or any other matter.